Re: Gunder Frank's response to ReOrientalism info (fwd)

"Have no friends not equal to yourself."

-- The Confucian Analects, †bk. 1:8, iii



Gunder Frank wrote:

> ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>                      ANDRE GUNDER FRANK
>           Visiting Professor  of  International Relations
> University of Miami           &         Florida International University
>
> 380 Giralda Ave. Apt 704                Tel: 1-305-648 1906
> Miami - Coral Gables FL                 Fax: 1-305-648 0149
> USA  33134                              e-mail:agfrank@chass.utoronto.ca
>
> Personal/Professional Home Page> http://csf.colorado.edu/archive/agfrank/
>
> My NATO/Kosovo Page> http://csf.colorado.edu/archive/agfrank/nato_kosovo/
>
> My professional/personal conclusion is the same as Pogo's -
>             We have met the enemy, and it is US
> ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>
> ---------- Forwarded message ----------
> Date: Mon, 20 Dec 1999 15:29:41 +0200
> From: Caglar KEYDER <keyder@boun.edu.tr>
> To: devoist@binghamton.edu, agfrank@chass.utoronto.ca
> Subject: Gunder Frank's response to ReOrientalism info
>
> Donna: please post to same B raudel Cent4r list thst reveived
> this announcement.
>
> Dear Giovanni,Immanuel and Samir
> I am more undeservedly honored than deservedly pleased by your surprise
> announcement about your reviews of my book. I suppose its was not kept a
> surprise/secret to honor me fest-schrift like, since you kindly already 
>did
> that  some years ago. So I suspect the secrecy was more so that I could 
>not
> ask you for a
> 'right of reply' in the same issue -- which would have made it into a sort
> of book 3 of ours --- which i actually proposed we do on this sort of
> topic, but you all declined, and now have gone off to do 'it' on your own.
> It reminds me of your shirking of Marta at Agra after i had broken my foot
> trytin to get on your bus to rise with you so that she had to travel
> and at Agra eat alone,  which is a pain that she took wiht her to the
> grave, accomjponaied mnaybe by one from me for not having cut off all
> relations to you all out of loyalty to her. I already told Samir about all
> this one day near the Pantheon in Paris, and explained that this was the
> reason
> that Marta refused to appear as co-author on our book 2.
> So what's the secrecy? Samir told me about his essay but did nt mention 
>the
> otehrs. When my Chinese publisher got wind
> of it, I sent you their inquiry for your reply. but i never got one. I
> guess I should have done what Marta said
> instead of celebbragting our 30th anniversary with Giovanni and Samir and
> the 25th with Immanuel this year.
>
> So you dont think I am writing this out of displeasure
> wioth what you wrote, I inform that I have not received or read what you
> wrote since I am writing curtesy of Calgar
> in Istanbul.
>
> gunder