< < <
Date Index > > > |
Re: CMP by Mike Alexander 29 March 2002 00:14 UTC |
< < <
Thread Index > > > |
From: "Carl H.A. Dassbach" <dassbach@mtu.edu>
> Capitalism is not, as Alexander asserts, simply another manifestation of > human greed. I didn't mention greed. I referred to capitalism as a "modern
form of the endless quest for power that is characteristic of all
societies".
I said nothing about a natural tendency to perform trade, nor did I say
capitalism was rooted in human nature. I did not say capitalism has always
been with us or that it doesn't exist. What I did say is (upon my
re-reading) pretty unclear. So I will try to clear it up.
I claim that a monetized economy is a necessary, but not sufficient
condition for a capitalistic society. I believe a feature of capitalism is
that ambitious persons perceive that commercial activity is a useful way to gain
power and "glory". The economic conditions necessary for capitalism
existed before the 15th century in Europe and elsewhere. Sophisticated
finance was carried out by the great banks in Sienna and Florence in the
early 14th century on a scale greater than 15th century Italian
finance. And as Frank points out, in Asia the economic conditions
were present too.
But this situation was not yet capitalism. What was missing is a
willingness for those at the very top of the social hierarchy to consider
commerce as a worthwhile activity suitable even for a gentleman. Compare
the voyages of Cheng Ho with those sponsored by Prince Henry the
Navigator. The former was a tour de force, sort of like the
US moon landing. The latter was part of a deliberate program to try to
enhance the power of Portugal using commercial means.
The first was simply a demonstration of a monarch's glory and is as old as
the pyramids. The second was capitalism and was something quite new.
Mike Alexander, author of
Stock Cycles: Why stocks won't beat money markets over the next 20 years and The Kondratiev Cycle: A generational interpretation http://www.net-link.net/~malexan/STOCK_CYCLES.htm |
< < <
Date Index > > > |
World Systems Network List Archives at CSF | Subscribe to World Systems Network |
< < <
Thread Index > > > |